Spurious health conditions: illnesses lacking necessity for medical intervention and reasons behind them

Spurious health conditions: illnesses lacking necessity for medical intervention and reasons behind them

In the intricate realm of medicine, where novel findings surge daily and the frontiers of knowledge broaden, ordinary human experiences or minor deviations are sometimes classified as ailments calling for treatment. However, this isn't always appropriate.

1. Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in Children that doesn't meet criteria:

ADHD, a genuine neurobiological disorder, necessitates serious diagnosis and a well-rounded treatment strategy. Yet, there has been a trend towards overdiagnosis, particularly in children who are more energetic, inquisitive, or struggling to conform to the academic environment.

Why not to treat:

Medications for ADHD (stimulants) come with side effects: side effects like loss of appetite, insomnia, and anxiety. Prescribing such drugs to a child without ADHD exposes them to unnecessary risks. Additionally, an ADHD diagnosis can negatively impact a child's self-esteem and social interactions.

Alternative approaches: Instead of medication, when a child requires more physical activity, structured routines, or academic assistance, educational and psychological methods are more effective.

1. Gut dysbiosis:

This expression is often used to refer to changes in the composition of gut microbiota. However, dysbiosis isn't a recognized medical disease in most countries. The composition of gut microbiota is a dynamic system that shifts regularly due to diet, stress, medication, and other aspects.

Why not to treat:

There are no clear diagnostic criteria: The composition of gut microbiota varies for each individual, and there isn't a "perfect" set of bacteria. Treatment is often ineffective: Probiotics and other drugs aimed at revitalizing gut microbiota might offer temporary relief, but they don't rectify the issue long-term.

Focus on symptoms: Instead of treating "dysbiosis", it's crucial to identify and address the causes of gut discomfort (e.g., food intolerance, stress, poor diet).

1. Vegeto-Vascular Dysfunction (VSD):

VSD - a collective term used to describe a broad range of symptoms such as headaches, dizziness, increased heart rate, blood pressure fluctuations, fatigue, and anxiety. In most countries, this diagnosis is not officially recognized as it doesn't describe a specific disease, but rather a set of nonspecific symptoms.

Why not to treat:

Lack of a unified approach to treatment: Since VSD is not a specific disease, there is no standard treatment protocol. Masking real problems: Symptoms attributed to VSD could indicate other, more serious ailments, such as anemia, thyroid issues, cardiovascular diseases, or anxiety disorders.

Fraudulent doctors have been accused of manipulating tests to extort money from patients, as previously reported by "Live Kuban".

Subscribe to our Telegram channel for the most important news: https://t.me/live_kuban

Regarding these conditions, discussions concerning diagnosis and treatment are shrouded in controversy due to diagnostic criteria, scientific evidence, and clinical practices.

Controversies in Diagnosing ADHD

• Diagnostic Criteria and Symptom Overlap: The DSM-5-TR criteria for ADHD demand at least six of nine symptoms in the inattentive or hyperactive-impulsive domains for those under 16, but symptom presentations can be faint or resemble normal childhood behavior, especially in girls and intellectually gifted children[2]. This can lead to both over- and under-diagnosis.
• Differentiation from Other Conditions: ADHD symptoms overlap with anxiety, depression, and other disorders, making diagnosis challenging and sometimes subjective[2][4].
• Treatment and Stigma: The use of stimulant medications, concerns about long-term effects, and potential for substance abuse add to the controversy, although recent research questions some assumptions about stimulant use and later substance abuse[3].
• Alternative Approaches: Some doctors, like Dr. Amen, employ controversial methods such as SPECT imaging for diagnosis, which isn't supported by most mainstream medical professionals due to lack of scientific validation[5].

Controversies Surrounding Gut Dysbiosis

• Lack of Consensus on Definition: Gut dysbiosis refers to an imbalance in the gut microbiota, but there is no universally accepted definition or diagnostic criteria.
• Link to Psychiatric Conditions Not Fully Understood: While research suggests a connection between gut health and neurological or psychiatric conditions (like ADHD), the evidence is still budding and inadequate for routine clinical application.
• Overlap with Other Health Issues: Symptoms attributed to gut dysbiosis are common to many gastrointestinal and systemic illnesses, making diagnosis and targeted treatment questionable.

Controversies Surrounding Vegeto-Vascular Dysfunction (VSD)

• Ambiguous Terminology and Lack of Recognition: VSD (also known as neurocirculatory asthenia or autonomic dysfunction) is not classified as a distinct diagnosis in international classification systems like the DSM or ICD.
• Symptom Overlap: Symptoms such as dizziness, fatigue, and palpitations are vague and can be attributed to many other medical conditions, making diagnosis and management difficult.
• Lack of Evidence-Based Treatment: There is limited scientific evidence supporting specific treatments for VSD, and management often depends on symptomatic treatment rather than addressing a clear underlying cause.

In summary, these debates emphasize the complexities and ongoing debates in the diagnosis and treatment of these conditions.

Here are the sentences containing the requested words:

1. Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD):

In the treatment strategy for ADHD, therapies and treatments (like medications and educational methods) should be applied judiciously, as it is a genuine neurobiological disorder.

1. Gut dysbiosis:

Gut dysbiosis, while not recognized as a medical disease in most countries, remains an area of significant interest in the health-and-wellness field, particularly concerning its possible connections with mental-health and fitness-and-exercise routines.

1. Vegeto-Vascular Dysfunction (VSD):

Although Vegeto-Vascular Dysfunction (VSD) isn't officially recognized as a specific disease, understanding its potential role in health and disease, especially in relation to science, is crucial for the development of effective therapies and treatments.

Read also: